Can I move a review to another product?
Moving reviews onto a different product, maybe with the intention of boosting its count or score, is what the CMA calls “catalogue abuse”. Moving a review to a product the customer actually bought, or is actually talking about, is just fixing an error.
Think about the customer’s experience
The CMA’s guidance on the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 has a name for this. Catalogue abuse, also called review hijacking or review merging. It is when a shop presents reviews of a different product to the one it actually associated with. It becomes a problem when it misleads the customer. If the reason for moving the review is to move the dial on a specific product’s rating or review count, then be very careful.
There are times when it is OK though. The guidance says “sharing” reviews can be OK. If the customer’s experience is the same, but perhaps a minor detail is different, then shared reviews are more likely to comply.
Nothing we found in the Act or the guidance deals with a review left on the wrong product by mistake. We are not lawyers, and this is not legal advice.
The same table top, just at a different size
Likely fine. Same maker, same build, and a shopper would have the same experience.
A bigger size, but built differently
The CMA’s own example of merging that could mislead.
A relisted product
The CMA says carrying old reviews can be a risk, but generally OK when it is just that the product has changed some meta.
A slow seller that needs help
A review of something else (but the wording is quite generic) is not acceptable. This is the case the rules are written for.
Before you move a review
Check what they bought
The original order says which product the customer ordered, if the review has been associated with another product, then moving it is actually putting it back where it belongs.
Read it for the product
A review that says “the 2m table” is about the 2m table. Moving it to the 1m table product would be a problem.
Share between variants, not products
Colours and finishes of one design are the easy case. Different products with a family name are not, however alike they look in the catalogue.
Never copy one review onto many
If a customer reviewed one product, the same review on five product pages counts that customer five times, in five averages. This is not allowed.
Every reply starts from an order
Each request carries a reference to its own order, and the customer’s reply brings it back to us. The review starts on what they bought because when the reply reaches you to publish, the first item in that order is already chosen as the product.
You can choose a different product, for a variant or a relisting, and that choice is yours. The rules above still need you to apply them because we do not compare the product you pick against the order.
The verification page does not show the order, but it does confirm the reply answered a genuine order of yours, from the address you wrote to.
Tied to an order
Every request carries its own reference.
Starts on what they bought
The order’s first item is chosen for you.
Your call to change
We do not check the product you pick.
A genuine order
The record confirms one stood behind the reply.
Questions
Can I merge reviews when I merge two products?
If they were really one product listed twice, yes. If they differed in a way a buyer would notice, keep the reviews apart, because merging them is the practice the CMA’s guidance warns about.
Can I import reviews from my supplier’s listing?
Those are reviews of somebody else’s sale, by people who did not buy from you. Presenting them as reviews of your product and service could be misleading.
Is this the same as review hijacking?
Yes. The CMA’s guidance uses catalogue abuse, review hijacking and review merging as names for the same practice.
A Trustpilot review is on the wrong profile. Can I move it?
You can ask. Trustpilot’s guidelines let a business ask to move a review that is on the wrong profile because it refers to one of the business’s other domains.
Reviews that start from the order they came from.
Two verified replies a month cost nothing, for as long as you want it, and the asking is not metered at all.