Skip to content
For shop owners

The law on fake reviews, and what your shop has to do

Publishing a fake or misleading review has been illegal in the UK since April 2025, and the duty rests with whoever shows the review. That covers your own product pages. Here is what you can change on a review, what you cannot, and where we can help.

What changed

The rules apply to your own product pages

Fake reviews are a banned practice

The Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024 made publishing fake and misleading reviews illegal outright, as well as incentivised reviews that do not say they were incentivised. Those bans took effect on 6 April 2025.

The CMA does not need a court

It can fine up to 10% of worldwide turnover, or £300,000 if that is greater, and impose it directly. Individuals can be fined up to £150,000. The first investigations under the new powers began in March 2026.

It is not just the big platforms

Anyone publishing consumer reviews has to take reasonable and proportionate steps to prevent, detect and remove fake ones. A shop displaying reviews on its own product pages is publishing consumer reviews.

What is yours to decide

What can I change on a review?

You keep control over three things when it comes to reviews.

What all three share is that none of them change what the customer said.

01

Whether you publish it at all. Deciding a reply is not going on your product page is your call, and it stays your call. That is curation, and curation is permitted.

How we helpWe hold the reply either way, with the outcome and the reason. If you are ever asked about the ones you left out, they are still there to show because the decision is recorded rather than hidden.

02

Leaving something out. A surname, a phone number, a paragraph about the weather, a complaint about a member of staff by name. You can publish the bit that is about the product and cut the rest.

How we helpThe record says every word still there is theirs, in their order, and that some was cut. It does not claim the cut preserved the meaning, because we cannot check that.

03

Taking one down later. A review you published can come down. The product was discontinued, the customer asked you to, you thought better of it.

How we helpThe record says the shop removed it, and when. The reviewer’s name is removed from the record, but it does not vanish, and it does not pretend the review was never there.

Don’t get caught out

What can’t I change on a review?

Four things to be careful about when showing your reviews.

Everything here boils down to changing what the customer said. None of it feels like lying at the time, which is precisely why it can catch people out.

A useful guide: if you would not be happy for the customer to see your version next to theirs, do not publish it.

01

The words themselves. You shouldn’t touch the grammar or even the spelling. You shouldn’t tweak a tepid sentence. A tidied review is an edited review.

How we helpEvery published word is checked against our copy of the email, by us rather than by you. Edit the review later and it is compared again, and the record updates with it.

02

Two replies joined into one. The same customer twice, or two customers combined into one better review. The upshot is a sentence nobody wrote.

How we helpA review answers one reply to one order. Anything on the page that cannot be tied back to the email we hold is reported.

03

Which product it is about. Shifting a review off the thing it was about and onto a thing that needs the help.

How we helpYour request carries a reference to its own order, and the reply brings it back for us to verify. The verification page does not show the order, but it does confirm the reply answered a genuine one of yours.

04

Who it came from. A first name that is not theirs, a review attached to a customer who did not write it, or one with no customer behind it at all.

How we helpWe check the reply came back from the address your shop wrote to. Where the sending provider signed the message we verify that server signature too.

Where we help

What the rules expect, and what we do about it

Nothing here makes your shop compliant on its own, and we are not lawyers. The decisions are still yours, and so is the written policy and the risk assessment the CMA expects you to keep.

What we can do is make those decisions checkable by someone who is not you. Most review setups cannot manage that at all.

What the rules expect What we do
Reasonable steps to check a review is genuine Every review starts as an email reply we hold in full, and we verify the signature the sending provider placed on it
Being able to show your working Every published review links to a page anyone can open, including the customer and the regulator
Not claiming things you do not know We report what we checked and say plainly what we did not. A shortened review says it was shortened
Keeping the evidence A review can still be checked after it was written because every reply is stored exactly as it was sent, for ever

Questions

Can I still choose which replies to publish?

Yes, and it is the first thing under what you can change. What you cannot do is hide the genuine negative ones to raise your average. Nobody reading a review of yours is being misled about that because our shopper page says plainly that a shop chooses what it publishes. What a verified review means

Can I fix a typo?

We wouldn’t. A corrected spelling is still an edit to what arrived, and the record will stop saying the review is word for word. Don’t worry, this is user generated content and their typo doesn’t have a bad effect on your product.

Does using VerifiedReply make us compliant?

No, and be wary of anyone who says their product does. Compliance is a set of decisions plus a policy you have written down. What we give you is the evidence underneath it: an independent record of where every review came from, held by someone other than you.

What do I send if we are asked?

The verification page links. Every published review has one, they do not expire, and they do not need us to be involved. A review can be checked long after the person who published it has left because we hold the original email for ever.

What about reviews we already have?

We cannot verify a review we did not collect, and we will not claim otherwise. Anything already on your product pages stays as it is. What we can do is ask your past customers properly, within a window you choose, so the reviews you collect from here have something behind them.

Does this apply outside the UK?

The DMCC Act is UK law. The United States has its own rule from the FTC covering much the same ground. Both hinge on the same two questions: is the review genuine, and does it say what the customer actually said.

Does this apply to testimonials?

Very likely, yes. The Act defines a consumer review as a review of a product, a trader or anything else relevant to a decision to buy, and the CMA calls that a broad concept. A client’s words about your business fit it, whatever you call them. The advertising code adds its own rules for a testimonial on your website: you need the person’s permission, and evidence that it is genuine. The risk to watch is publishing only the glowing ones. Using an email as a review or testimonial

Run a shop?

Reviews you can hand to someone else to check.

Review requests are unlimited, and two verified replies a month cost nothing with our free tier.

How VerifiedReply works